Why Are Mortgage Rates Different From Lender to Lender?
Mortgage rates are a critical factor in the home buying process, yet many prospective homeowners may wonder why these rates vary from lender to lender. This article aims to shed light on this often confusing aspect of the mortgage industry. It is essential to understand these variations as they can significantly impact the cost of your mortgage over time. Whether you’re a first-time homebuyer or an existing homeowner looking to refinance, renew, or transfer your mortgage with another lender, this article will serve as a thorough guide.
The Basics of Mortgage Rates
Mortgage rates are the interest rates that lenders charge borrowers on their mortgage loans. These rates are a reflection of the cost of borrowing and are influenced by a variety of factors, including market conditions, lender policies, and borrower characteristics. Understanding these rates is crucial for potential borrowers as it directly impacts the total cost of the mortgage and the monthly payments. In the following sections, we’ll delve deeper into the types of mortgage rates and why they vary.
Fixed-rate mortgages are loans where the interest rate remains the same for the entire term of the mortgage. The interest rate on these mortgages is determined by the bond market. When bond yields rise, fixed mortgage rates typically follow. Fixed-rate mortgages offer stability as the mortgage payments remain the same throughout the term. This can be particularly beneficial for budgeting purposes and provides a sense of security against fluctuating market conditions.
Variable-rate mortgages, on the other hand, have interest rates that can change during the term of the mortgage. These rates are typically tied to the Bank of Canada’s policy rate. When the Bank of Canada changes its policy rate, variable mortgage rates usually change. This means that if the Bank of Canada increases its policy rate, your mortgage rate and therefore your mortgage payment will likely increase. In the past variable-rate mortgages have offered lower rates compared to fixed-rate mortgages but they come with the risk of rate increases, which has happened over the last couple of years as inflation increased. However, if you’re comfortable with some level of risk and believe that rates will decrease, a variable-rate mortgage could potentially save you money over the long term.
Why Mortgage Rates Vary
Mortgage rates vary among lenders due to a multitude of factors, each contributing to the final rate offered to a borrower. Here are some of the reasons:
- Lenders’ Business Strategies: Lenders aim to attract prospective home buyers to apply for a mortgage with them. To achieve this, they often advertise the best possible interest rate they can provide. However, not every borrower that applies for or gets approved for a mortgage will be eligible for this low interest rate. This variation in rates is a key aspect of the competitive nature of the mortgage industry. Lenders may also adjust their rates based on their current portfolio of loans and their desired risk level. For instance, if a lender has a high proportion of high-risk loans in its portfolio, it may offer higher rates to new borrowers to balance out the risk. This strategy allows lenders to manage their risk exposure while still attracting new customers.
- Product Differences: To keep rates low, lenders often remove flexibility. In exchange for that rock-bottom deal, for example, they’ll often limit prepayment, porting or refinance options or impose bigger penalties for early termination. That’s why some of the lowest rates are called “low-frills” mortgages. Other times a lender will lure people in with big cash rebates, in lieu of lower rates. These product differences can significantly impact the rates offered by different lenders. It’s important for borrowers to understand these differences and choose a mortgage product that best suits their needs and financial situation.
- Funding Costs: It usually costs lenders less to fund high-ratio insured mortgages than uninsured mortgages. The customer pays the insurance premium, risk of loss is lower and the capital costs are smaller. Some lenders just have higher funding costs and/or operating expenses per loan to begin with. For example, a tiny credit union has to pay more for its funds than a giant multi-national bank, and has many loans to spread its costs over. These funding costs can significantly impact the rates offered by different lenders. Understanding these costs can help borrowers make more informed decisions when choosing a lender.
- Competition and Market Saturation: The more saturated a real estate market is, the cheaper mortgage rates can get. This is because lenders compete for a share of the market, and one of the ways they can attract borrowers is by offering competitive rates. In areas with less competition, lenders may charge higher rates. This dynamic can lead to significant variations in mortgage rates across different regions and markets. Borrowers can potentially take advantage of this by shopping around for the best rates.
- Risk Premiums: Lenders may charge higher rates to borrowers they deem riskier. For example, if a borrower has a lower credit score, the lender may charge a higher rate to compensate for the increased risk of default. This risk premium can lead to significant variations in mortgage rates among different borrowers. It underscores the importance of maintaining a good credit score when applying for a mortgage.
- Tiers of Rates Based on Loan-to-Value Ratios (LTVs): Lenders often offer different rates based on different LTVs. For example, a borrower with an LTV of 65% may qualify for a lower rate than a borrower with an LTV of 80%. These LTV ratios can lead to significant variations in mortgage rates among different borrowers. It underscores the importance of saving for a larger down payment when seeking a mortgage.
- Amortization Periods: Some lenders charge small rate premiums if the amortization period is extended from 25 to 30 years. This can lead to variations in mortgage rates among different borrowers. While a longer amortization period can result in lower monthly payments, it can also result in higher total interest costs over the life of the loan.
- Type of Mortgage Transfer: Some lenders charge rate premiums if the transfer of a mortgage from another lender was originally registered as a collateral charge instead of a standard charge. This can lead to variations in mortgage rates among different borrowers. It’s important for borrowers to understand the implications of different types of transfers when considering switching lenders.
- Pre-Approvals: Pre-approvals are regularly offered a rate that is usually higher than the regular approval rate. This can lead to variations in mortgage rates among different borrowers. While pre-approvals can provide borrowers with an idea of how much they can afford, they should be aware that the final rate may be different.
- Bridge Financing: Bridge financing is usually at a higher rate due to the short nature of the loan. This can lead to variations in mortgage rates among different borrowers. While bridge financing can be a useful tool for borrowers who are buying and selling a home at the same time, they should be aware of the higher costs associated with it.
- Mortgages with Cashbacks: Mortgages with cashbacks usually have higher rates than regular mortgages as the cashback is built into the rate. This can lead to variations in mortgage rates among different borrowers. While cashbacks can provide immediate financial relief, borrowers should consider whether the higher rate is worth it in the long run.
- Stress Test Exemptions: Some lenders may allow people to be qualified without using the stress test, and may charge a higher mortgage rate for that type of mortgage. This can lead to variations in mortgage rates among different borrowers. While avoiding the stress test may allow borrowers to qualify for a larger loan, they should be aware of the higher costs associated with it.
- Insured and Insurable Mortgages: Insured and insurable mortgages would have a lower interest rate than uninsured conventional mortgages. This can lead to variations in mortgage rates among different borrowers. While insurance can result in a lower rate, borrowers should consider the additional cost of the insurance premium. For insurable mortgages, the insurance premium is typically paid by the lender.
- Mortgages for Rental Properties: Mortgages for rental properties will have a higher rate than mortgages for owner-occupied properties. This can lead to variations in mortgage rates among different borrowers. While rental properties can provide a source of income, borrowers should be aware of the higher costs associated with these types of mortgages. Lenders often view rental properties as riskier, leading to higher rates.
- Second Mortgages: If a lender is offering a second mortgage, the rate would almost always be higher than the rate on the first mortgage. This can lead to variations in mortgage rates among different borrowers. While second mortgages can provide additional financing, borrowers should be aware of the higher costs associated with them. Lenders view second mortgages as riskier because they are second in line to be repaid if the borrower defaults.
- Variable Rate Mortgages: Variable rate mortgages may vary from lender to lender, as this type of mortgage is based on the Prime rate and then a premium or a discount is applied to get to the actual rate. These discounts and premiums can vary from lender to lender, leading to variations in mortgage rates. Additionally, some lenders’ Prime rates are not the same as other lenders, which can affect the final variable rate offered to the borrower.
- Business for Self (Alternative Income) Programs: An example of a mortgage program with higher insurance premiums would be The Business for Self – ALT A program that is designed for the self-employed individuals that cannot provide traditional sources of income verification. This can lead to variations in mortgage rates among different borrowers. While this program can provide self-employed individuals with access to mortgage financing, they should be aware of the higher costs associated with it. This type of mortgage might not necessarily have difference in mortgage rates from lender to lender, but it have a higher default insurance premium, which will result in a higher payment, as well there will be lenders that might opt-out of offering this type of mortgage product.
This thorough analysis should provide a clearer understanding of why mortgage rates vary from lender to lender.
Impact of Variation in Mortgage Rates
The variation in mortgage rates can significantly affect the amount you pay toward interest-carrying costs on your mortgage. Therefore, understanding what goes into determining these rates will help you better compare scenarios when looking at rates offered to you. It’s also important to consider the impact of these variations on your long-term financial plans. For example, a lower rate can save you thousands of dollars over the life of your mortgage, making it a critical factor in your home buying decision.
How to Navigate Mortgage Rates
Navigating mortgage rates can be challenging, especially for first-time homebuyers. It’s important to do your research, understand the different types of rates, and consider your financial situation and risk tolerance. Consulting with a mortgage broker can also be beneficial. Mortgage brokers, acting as intermediaries between lenders and borrowers, can assist borrowers by providing personalized advice. They explain the pros and cons of different mortgage options and help find a mortgage with a competitive rate that suits the borrower’s situation.
In conclusion, mortgage rates vary from lender to lender due to a variety of factors, including the lender’s business model, the borrower’s financial profile, and the type of mortgage. By understanding these factors, prospective homeowners can make more informed decisions when choosing a mortgage lender.
We at TheBroker.ca Ltd, can offer you more helpful advice on getting a mortgage, current mortgage rates, and understanding the factors that influence these rates. Contact us today for a free consultation! For any questions or further assistance, feel free to reach out to us at TheBroker.ca Ltd. via our website or call us at (519) 252-9665.
This article was brought to you by TheBroker.ca Ltd., a licensed mortgage brokerage. Our licensing status with the Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRA) can be confirmed through this link.